Statistical Analysis

Proportion of Deaths: Clinic 1 vs Clinic 2 (1841โ€“1846)

Year Clinic 1 (proportion) Clinic 2 (proportion)
1841 0.0781 0.0352
1842 0.1576 0.076
1843 0.0895 0.0599
1844 0.0824 0.023
1845 0.069 0.0204
1846 0.1145 0.028

Monthly Proportion of Deaths (Clinic 1)

Mean before washing
0.105
Mean after washing
0.0211
Mean difference
-0.084

Handwashing reduced the proportion of deaths by approximately -0.084 (absolute).

Bootstrap 95 % Confidence Interval (3 000 resamples)

Lower bound (2.5 %)
-0.1017
Upper bound (97.5 %)
-0.067

With 95 % confidence, handwashing reduced the monthly death proportion by between 10.17% and 6.7% (absolute reduction).

Welch's t-Test: Before vs After Handwashing

t-statistic
9.6101
p-value
1.45e-15
โœ… The difference is statistically significant (p < 0.05). Handwashing provably reduced mortality.

Conclusions

  • Clinic 1 (medical students performing autopsies) had consistently higher death proportions than Clinic 2 (midwife students) from 1841โ€“1846.
  • After Semmelweis mandated handwashing in June 1847, deaths fell by roughly -0.084 in absolute proportion.
  • Bootstrap 95 % CI: [-0.1017, -0.067] โ€” equivalent to a 10.17โ€“6.7 percentage-point reduction.
  • Welch's t-test: t = 9.6101, p = 1.45e-15. Result is statistically significant.

Clinic Comparison Table

Year Clinic 1 (proportion) Clinic 2 (proportion)
1841 0.0781 0.0352
1842 0.1576 0.076
1843 0.0895 0.0599
1844 0.0824 0.023
1845 0.069 0.0204
1846 0.1145 0.028